Pros and Cons of Cutting

            Fear is the first word that comes to mind when hearing athletes speak of tryout day. Many kids are scared to see what decisions the coaches will make for that season. Many schools today cut, or choose only a certain amount of people, for their sports team. This topic is very controversial across the nation and has many sides to weigh.

            The first reason schools might want, or even need, to cut is merely because their school is too big to accommodate that many athletes. This issue is common in bigger cities and cutting is not an option. Another reason schools choose to cut is to have a more one on one focus during practice. Some coaches believe their team will get to its highest skill level if there are less athletes to work with and more coaches to teach. They believe the athletes will improve faster without adding to distraction, in this case extra people.

            One reason schools choose not to cut, is because they want to give every athlete an opportunity to grow and learn. This not only allows for competition, but more people to choose from when it gets to the varsity level. These types of coaches believe that everyone deserves a chance to improve no matter what stage they are in. This can lead to overcrowding and many people sitting on the bench. This then leaves the choice to play to the athlete. If they don’t want to sit they need to either improve or unfortunately quit.

            I have been very lucky in my years to have always attended a no cut policy enforced school. I believe this allows for athletes to grow by competing with others. This also helps athletes learn quickly. If you fall behind this makes your opponent that much more ahead of you. The choice to cut is very difficult and depends on your situation. Although I believe schools should not cut, I do not believe club teams shouldn’t. Club teams are for high level competition and require a huge amount of dedication. Playing for a private club team is an honor and should be earned. Remember your off-season is just as important, if not more, than when you’re in-season.